Sifa Lyrics

Why Why Why by Allison Eide cover art

Allison Eide - Why Why Why Lyrics

Artist:
Allison Eide
Album:
idk - EP
Official Release:
Nov. 7, 2025

Community reviewed

Community Contributors

2 contributors

BJ Lyrics
Zion Music Review

Verified by Sifa Lyrics

View contribution history
  1. Lyrics by BJ

Lyrics

Verse 1


Drivin’ home at 8:05
I sit in silence, not a song could help me through this
Tears fall at 8:09
I gave You all my faith, just to lose everything
And I don’t get it


Pre-Chorus


I’ve been singing so loud with my hands high
But I’m dyin’ inside


Chorus


Why, why, why? (Ooh)
And every single night, I’ve been sobbin’ on the bathroom floor
And You are silent
Why, why, why? (Ooh)
How much can a heart take without knowin’ why?
Why, why?


Verse 2


I trusted You in that hospital room
But at the final breath, You cut the last breath
And I don’t get it


Pre-Chorus


I’ve been singing so loud with my hands high
But I’m dyin’ inside


Chorus


Why, why, why? (Ooh)
And every single night, I’ve been sobbin’ on the bathroom floor
And You are silent
Why, why, why? (Ooh)
How much can a heart take without knowin’ why?


Bridge


Why are all my friends depressed? And why’s the church ignorin’ them?
Why’d my generation grow up just to spend a lifetime healin’?
Why is there disease and illness? Why is my dad in the grave?
Why did I receive a call from a little girl dying of AIDS?
Why do You even allow this? What did she ever do to you?
How can You just sit in silence? But who am I to question You?
And I don’t get it
Oh, I’m broken
Jesus, I trust You are in this


Pre-Chorus


I’ve been singing so loud with my hands high
But I’m dyin’ inside


Chorus


Why, why, why? (Ooh)
And every single night, I’ve been sobbin’ on the bathroom floor
And You are silent
Why, why, why? (Ooh)
How much can a heart take without knowin’ why?


Outro


(Why are all my friends depressed? And why’s the church ignorin’ them?)
Why, why, why?
(Why’d my generation grow up just to spend a lifetime healin’?)
Why, why, why, oh? (Ooh)
(Why is there disease and illness? Why is my dad in the grave?)
Why, why, why? (Ooh)
(Why did I receive a call from a little girl dying of AIDS?)
Why, why?


Video

Meaning & Inspiration

“Why Why Why” is a lament shaped by grief, unanswered prayer, and the strain of trusting God while suffering remains unexplained. Its precise memories of driving home, a hospital room, and nights spent crying give the questions a concrete weight. The narrator does not hide anger or confusion behind worship language; raised hands and loud singing exist beside inward collapse. Questions about illness, depression, death, and a hurting generation widen the lament beyond one loss without offering a simple answer.

The crucial turn comes in the admission that the narrator is broken, followed by a declaration of trust in Jesus within the pain. That trust does not erase the repeated “why,” and the song’s refusal to manufacture closure is central to its meaning. Its language closely resembles biblical lament, especially passages where faithful speakers ask how long God will seem silent. The song therefore portrays questioning and faith as present at the same time, with trust expressed not through certainty about circumstances but through continued speech to God.

Related Scripture

  • Psalm 13:1-2 David asks how long God will seem absent while sorrow fills his heart.
  • Psalm 22:1-2 The psalm voices anguish when cries to God appear to receive no answer.
  • Mark 9:24 A distressed father confesses belief while honestly acknowledging his struggle.