Riley Clemmons - Broken Prayers Lyrics

Video

Riley Clemmons - Broken Prayers (Official Video)

Meaning & Inspiration

There is a distinct danger in the way we often approach the throne of grace—a tendency to treat it like a diplomatic meeting rather than a collision with the Holy. Riley Clemmons hits a nerve when she sings about having been "taught how to talk to You / Hold it together / Make the bad look better." We have developed a vernacular of performance, a curated liturgy of the self that assumes God prefers a polished presentation. It is a subtle, dangerous form of works-righteousness: the belief that if we sanitize our agony, we are more palatable to the Almighty.

But the doctrine of the Incarnation suggests otherwise. If the Word became flesh and dwelt among us, then He is acquainted with the very biology of our suffering. When Clemmons confesses, "You’re not afraid of all the things I feel / So why am I afraid of being real," she is touching on the tension between our shame and the reality of the Imago Dei. We act as if our "messy words" catch God off guard, as if He hasn’t already accounted for every fracture in our soul. To hide our pain is to act as if Christ’s work on the Cross was insufficient to cover the parts of our lives we find embarrassing. It is a denial of the sufficiency of His sacrifice.

The line that stops me is: "You don't care if it ain't poetry / 'Cause all of my edges / They're a little rough / But that's all I got to bring." There is a rugged honesty here that borders on the Psalms of Lament. We are so often obsessed with the aesthetic of worship—the smooth, the harmonious, the rhythmic—forgetting that the groaning of the Spirit (Romans 8:26) is rarely melodic. In the tradition of the reformers, we talk about the "priesthood of all believers," which implies we have direct access to the Father. Yet, we insist on wearing a mask before we approach Him, as if we still need a mediator between our genuine selves and our Creator.

When the artist sings that God wants "every scar and every fear," she is articulating a profound theological truth: that propitiation has already dealt with our darkness. If the debt is paid, then the "rough edges" of our existence are not barriers to entry; they are the very ground upon which He meets us. I find myself wondering why we persist in this performative Christianity, this "bow my head say amen, yeah that'll do" mentality. It is a hollow shell. It keeps us distant, safe, and entirely unchanged.

If we truly believe that God meets us "at our worst," then our prayers do not need to be poetry. They just need to be honest. But honesty requires the death of the ego, and that is a painful price to pay. We are terrified of being known, because to be known is to realize that our self-made righteousness is nothing more than filthy rags. Perhaps the most "real" prayer we can offer is the one that admits we have spent our whole lives trying to look better than we are. It is the prayer that stops apologizing for the wreckage and finally asks to be rebuilt.