Contemplating Controversy: Examining the Biblical Validity of Centering Prayer

Discover the controversy surrounding centering prayer among Christians. Explore its origins, definition, and biblical alignment. Is it a valid form of prayer? Find out now.

Centering prayer is a method of prayer that has been gaining popularity among Christians in recent times. But is this practice biblical? In this article, we will explore the origins of centering prayer, its definition, and the controversy surrounding it. We will also delve into what the Bible says about prayer and examine whether this practice aligns with biblical teachings.

What is Centering Prayer?

Centering prayer is a prayer practice that involves sitting in silence and focusing on a word or phrase to quiet the mind and draw closer to God. It is a form of contemplative prayer that has its roots in ancient Christian monasticism.

The practice was revived in the 1970s by Trappist monk Thomas Keating, who developed a method of centering prayer that drew on the teachings of the Desert Fathers and other early Christian mystics. Keating taught that centering prayer is a way of opening ourselves up to the presence and action of God within us.

The Controversy Surrounding Centering Prayer

Despite its popularity, centering prayer has been the subject of controversy in Christian circles. Some critics argue that it is a form of eastern meditation that is incompatible with Christian beliefs and practices. Others contend that it is a valid form of prayer that can enhance one's spiritual life.

One of the main objections to centering prayer is that it involves emptying the mind, which is seen as a form of self-hypnosis or a way of opening oneself up to other spiritual forces. However, proponents of centering prayer argue that it is not about emptying the mind but rather about focusing it on God.

Another criticism of centering prayer is that it is a form of self-centered spirituality that emphasizes personal experience over biblical truth. But defenders of the practice argue that it can actually deepen one's understanding of scripture and lead to a more authentic relationship with God.

What Does the Bible Say About Prayer?

To determine whether centering prayer is biblical, we must first examine what the Bible says about prayer. Prayer is a central part of the Christian faith, and the Bible contains numerous examples of people praying to God. From the Lord's Prayer to the prayers of David and Paul, we see that prayer is a way of communicating with God and expressing our needs, desires, and gratitude.

But prayer is not just about speaking to God; it is also about listening to Him. Jesus often withdrew to pray in solitude, and he taught his disciples to do the same. In Matthew 6:6, he says, "But when you pray, go into your room, close the door and pray to your Father, who is unseen. Then your Father, who sees what is done in secret, will reward you."

In other words, prayer is not just about reciting words or performing rituals; it is about cultivating a personal relationship with God. It is about opening ourselves up to His presence and allowing Him to work in our lives.

Is Centering Prayer Biblical?

So, is centering prayer biblical? The answer is yes and no. On the one hand, there is nothing inherently un-biblical about sitting in silence and focusing on God's presence. In fact, many biblical characters did just that. David often spoke of waiting on God and seeking His face (Psalm 27:8, Psalm 105:4), and Elijah heard God's voice in the stillness after a great wind, earthquake, and fire (1 Kings 19:11-13).

On the other hand, the practice of centering prayer as it is commonly taught today may not be completely in line with biblical principles. For example, the emphasis on repeating a word or phrase can be seen as a form of mantra meditation, which is not a biblical practice. Additionally, the idea of "letting go" or "surrendering" can be interpreted in ways that are contrary to biblical teachings.

Overall, the question of whether centering prayer is biblical will depend on how it is practiced and understood. If it is approached as a way of quieting the mind and focusing on God's presence, it can be a valid form of prayer. However, if it involves elements that are contrary to biblical teachings, it should be avoided.

Final Thoughts

In conclusion, centering prayer is a controversial practice that has sparked debate among Christians. While it is not explicitly mentioned in the Bible, there are biblical principles that can be applied to evaluate its validity. Ultimately, the decision to practice centering prayer should be based on a careful study of scripture and a discernment of the Holy Spirit's leading.

FAQs

1. Is centering prayer a form of meditation?

Centering prayer shares some similarities with eastern meditation practices, but it is not the same thing. While it involves sitting in silence and focusing on a word or phrase, its goal is to draw closer to God rather than to achieve a state of inner peace or enlightenment.

2. Can centering prayer be practiced by people of all faiths?

Centering prayer is a Christian prayer practice that is based on biblical principles. While people of other faiths may find it helpful to sit in silence and reflect on spiritual themes, the specific method of centering prayer is best suited for Christians.

3. How long should I practice centering prayer?

Centering prayer can be practiced for as little as ten minutes or as long as an hour or more. The important thing is to set aside a regular time each day to sit in silence and focus on God's presence.

4. Is it necessary to use a specific word or phrase in centering prayer?

The specific word or phrase used in centering prayer is not as important as the intention behind it. The goal is to focus the mind on God and open oneself up to His presence. Some people may find it helpful to use a word or phrase that has personal significance, while others may prefer to simply focus on the breath or the sound of silence.

5. Can centering prayer be combined with other forms of prayer?

Yes, centering prayer can be combined with other forms of prayer, such as intercession, thanksgiving, and confession. In fact, centering prayer can enhance one's ability to pray in other ways by cultivating a deeper awareness of God's presence.